I'm going to try and pepper the rest of my 2011 posts with reviews of the best books of the year. They won't be in any particular order and, of course, on December 31 I'll post my full annual Top 10. So here goes with one that I'm sure we will be seeing on almost every Best of '11 list:
The Submission by Amy Waldman
The terrorist attacks of September 11 2001 have proven a spectacular stumbling block for America’s literary giants. Don Delillo failed dismally with his novel, Falling Man. John Updike similarly penned a stinker called Terrorist. Indeed, it took an Irish expat, Colum McCann to write the first great novel about that terrible day; Let The Great World Spin came out in 2009 and has yet to be surpassed as a work of true compassion, subtlety and insight. And it didn't even mention the attacks.
Now it seems a debut novelist has written the first great post-September 11 American novel, one which captures the pulse of a nation crippled by fear and grief on the one hand and buoyed by hope and defiance on the other. The Submission rests on a simple premise: the city of New York holds a blind competition to design the permanent memorial at Ground Zero. The selection committee, made up of government lackies, socialites and a single representative of the victims’ families, reviews the submissions without knowing the names of the entrants. Following considerable argument, they defer to the preference of the victim’s representative, Claire Burwell, and choose a beautiful garden surrounded by walls with the names of the fallen, only to discover its creator is one Mohammad Khan. Hardly the apple pie name they had hoped for.
What follows is a mad scramble to backtrack, justify and second-guess in which Waldman subjects all sides to wide-ranging excoriation. There are the obvious targets: the press who feast on the controversy and lace their stories with half-truths and sensationalist provocations; the flag-waving zealots baying for blood, who start a wave of racist attacks on Muslim women, pulling off their burqas at every opportunity; the flip-flop politicos who chase the vote at the expense of even the most basic decency; and, of course, the Muslim extremists seeking to co-opt Khan for their cause.
To her credit, Waldman is not satisfied simply taking easy pot shots. Even the more sympathetic characters have agendas and are prone to infuriating thoughts and actions. Burwell is divisive and self-righteous. Khan himself is arrogant and unwilling to do anything to quell the controversy. Only Asma Aswan, a woman whose husband wasn’t listed among the victims because he was an illegal immigrant sweeping the Trade Centre’s floors, comes across as truly innocent but hers is ultimately the saddest fate.
For the first three quarters, The Submission is an almost perfect novel, examining the dangers of knee-jerk reactions and questioning what it means to be a victim, what it means to be Muslim and, ultimately, what it means to be American in the wake of the this century's defining moment. Unfortunately, Waldman veers wildly off the rails towards the end, with a fairly predictable crescendo and one of the most unnecessary epilogues I have ever read. Students visit Khan twenty years later to discuss the controversy, and we learn the fates of all the characters. It is a clumsy, desperate end in which perhaps lies a crucial, if unintended, lesson of this otherwise outstanding book; some tragedies are just so immense that there can never be satisfactory closure.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
About Me
- The Bookworm
- When faced with a choice between a new book and the next meal, I will always choose the book. After all, paper is edible!
READ ME!
COMMENTS
Comments, abuse, argument and flattery are all welcome. Just click on the comments field and blurt away!
Email Me!
Got something to say but can't get the stupid comment box to work. Or just want to love/revile me? Send your deepest darkest thoughts to bramp@brampresser.com
Tweets For Bookworms
Follow me @BramPresser
BOOK NERDS UTD!
Blog Archive
Take The Bait!
Categories
- 2011 In Review
- 2013 in Review
- 2014 In Review
- 2015 In Review
- 2016 in Review
- 2017 In Review
- 2018 In Review
- 2019 in Review
- 2020 In Review
- 2021 In Review
- best of 2009
- Best of 2010
- Best of 2011
- Best of 2012
- Best of 2013
- Best of 2014
- Best of 2016
- Best of 2017
- best of 2018
- Best of 2019
- Best of 2020
- Best of 2021
- Best of the Decade
- Books of 2010
- Books of 2011
- Books of 2012
- Books of 2013
- Books of 2014
- Books of 2015
- Books of 2016
- Books of 2017
- Books of 2018
- Books That Made Me
- Dasa Drndic
- DEAR
- First World Reading Problems
- Genreary
- Independent Bookstores
- Literary Festivals
- Literary Prizes
- Microviews
- Musing
- Novella
- Rant
- Review
- Saramago
- The 2010 Challenge
- The April Challenge
- The August Challenge
- The December Challenge
- The February Challenge
- The July Challenge
- The June Challenge
- The Library
- The March Challenge
- The May Challenge
- The November Challenge
- The September Challenge
- Translation
- Visual Diary
- Writing
0 comments:
Post a Comment